you're reading...
Human Rights & Social Issues

China: Justice at last for criminal defence lawyers persecuted in Beihai

Li Zhuang

Li Zhuang

There have been lots of changes since Bo Xilai took over the reigns especially the sweeping anti-corruption drive, the closure of black jails that local governments used to lock up petitioners and informers, the imprisonment of thugs who intercepted petitioners and the payment of compensation to illegally detained petitioner.

For me, however, the most important change is the quick decision after Xi took over of a case in Beihai City where four defence lawyers were wronged and put under house arrest for defending innocent clients.

Since Bo Xilai persecuted defence lawyer Li Zhuang, persecution of criminal case defence lawyers has become a national trend. As a result, except for a small number of lawyers who bravely fight for the rule of law and human rights, few lawyers dare to act as defence lawyers in criminal litigation.

A war to defend the rule of law began. On the one hand, the National People’s Congress (NPC, China’s parliament) led by Wu Bangguo, a Shanghai faction heavyweight, revised China’s criminal procedure law to protect lawyers’ right of defence. Wu’s action was the earliest sign of the power struggle related to the rule of law between Bo Xilai and those who wanted the rule of law, including the Shanghai faction and Qiao Shi’s faction

On the other hand, in order to prevent Bo’s malpractice of persecuting defence lawyer from spreading to the whole nation, dozens of rights lawyers formed the well-known “Beihai Lawyer Group” to defend lawyers’ right of defence in the notorious Beihai Case in which Yang Zaixin and other three lawyers were arrested for their defence of their five clients.

According to Ming Pao and SCMP, the fact of the Beihai Case was very clear: in November 2009, A youngster Huang Huanhai disappeared after his group of youngsters quarrelled and then fought with another group of youngsters. The police took the group of five who fought with Huang’s group and regarded them as suspects. Five days later, Huang’s body was found and the five suspects were accused of Huang’s murder.

It was reported: No evidence was found to accuse the suspects of Huang’s murder, but in order to obtain the achievement of breaking all the homicide cases within the year, the police forced the suspects to admit that they killed Huang with a knife. However, no knife wound at all was found by autopsy in Huang’s body.

The suspects’ four lawyers including Yang Zaixin defended the suspects and told them to refuse to admit what they had not done. They thus offended the police and prosecutor who had been used to disallow any objection since Mao era. Infuriated, the police and prosecutor framed up the lawyers’ crime of instigating the suspects to commit perjury.

In June 2011, they detained the four lawyers. Yang Xuelin who defend Li Zhuang in Li’s case and other lawyers in the country, were worried that Bo Xilai’s malpractice of persecuting defence lawyer Lizhuang was spreading to the whole nation. They organised the above mentioned “Beihai Lawyer Group” and raised 450,000 yuan ($72,300) funds for the four lawyers’ defence. They hoped that by so doing, they might prevent the spreading of Bo’s malpractice of persecuting defence lawyers.

Through their efforts, three of the lawyers were soon released, but Yang Zaixin remained in custody until he was placed under house arrest in March 2012.

What the group did roused media concerns and the group’s actions were described as “Defence of Law in Beihai”. Their example was later followed by other lawyers who organised groups to protect defence lawyers in Guiyang City, Guizhou Province, Changshu City, Jiangsu Province and others.

After three years of deadlock, on February 6, 2013, Beihai Intermediate People’s Court finally gave the verdict to release one of the suspects and give fixed-term imprisonment to the other four for another crime of creating disturbance. As the four had been detained for a term longer than their terms of imprisonment, they were all immediately released.

At the same time, all the four lawyers accused of instigating the suspects to commit perjury have reveived notices from the court that their cases had been withdrawn.

Yang Xuelin told Ming Pao that Beihai Case was a milestone for China’s criminal defence lawyers and “laid foundation for criminal defence lawyers’ position and role in China’s implementation of law.” He said that had Yang Zaixin not persisted in the defence, some of the defendants might have long been put to death.

Yang Zaixin will apply to the state for compensation for the detention and house arrest he wrongly suffered and plans to sue the police and prosecutor for their liability in persecuting him. Yang Xuelin and others have helped the four convicted for creating disturbance to appeal for their innocence. Now all the clues to the murder case have been lost as the police focused on framing up the defendants right from the beginning, and thus lost the opportunity to find the clues through investigation.

Sources: Ming Pao, SCMP

About chankaiyee2

Author of the book "Tiananmen's Tremendous Achievements" about how with the help of Tiananmen Protests, talented scholars with moral integrity seized power in the Party and state and brought prosperity to China. The second edition of the book will be published within a few days to mark the 25th anniversary of Tiananmen Protests All the parts in the first edition remain in the second edition with a few changes due to information available later and better understanding. There are also some changes for improvements of style. The new parts are Chapters 12-19 on events in China after the first edition was published: The fierce power struggle for succession between reformists and conservatives; Xi Jinping winning all elders’ support during his mysterious disappearance for 2 weeks in early September, 2012; and Xi Jinping Cyclone. Chan Kai Yee's new book: SPACE ERA STRATEGY: The Way China Beats The US An eye-opening book that tells the truth how the US is losing to China. The US is losing as it adopts the outdated strategy of Air-Sea Battle while China adopts the space era strategy to pursue integrated space and air capabilities: It is losing due to its diplomacy that has given rise to Russian-Chinese alliance. US outdated strategy has enabled China to catch up and surpass the US in key weapons: Hypersonic weapons (HGV) that Pentagon regards as the weapon that will dominate the world in the future. Aerospaceplane in China’s development of space-air bomber that can engage enemy anywhere in the world within an hour and destroy an entire aircraft carrier battle group within minutes. Anti-satellite (ASAT) weapons, anti-ASAT weapons, stealth aircrafts, drones, AEW&C, etc. The book gives detailed descriptions of China’s weapon development based on information mainly from Chinese sources that the author monitors closely. U.S. Must Not Be Beaten by China! China is not a democracy. Its political system cannot prevent the emergence of a despotic leader or stop such a leader when he begins to bring disasters to people. A few decades ago, Mao Zedong, the worst tyrant in world history did emerge and bring disasters to Chinese people. He wanted to fight a nuclear war to replace capitalism with communism but could not bring nuclear holocaust to world people as China was too weak and poor at that time. If a despot like Mao Zedong emerges when China has surpassed the US in military strength, world people will suffer the misery experienced by Chinese people in Mao era. China surpassing the US in GDP is not something to worry about as China has the heavy burden to satisfy its huge population, but China surpassing the US in military strength will be world people’s greatest concern if China remains an autocracy. US people are of much better quality than Chinese people. What they lack is a wise leader to adopt the correct strategy and diplomacy and the creative ways to use its resources in developing its military capabilities. I hope that with the emergence of a great leader, the US can put an end to its decline and remain number one in the world. China, US, space era strategy, air-sea battle, space-air bomber, arms race, weapon development, chan kai yee


4 thoughts on “China: Justice at last for criminal defence lawyers persecuted in Beihai

  1. Reblogged this on CHINDIA ALERT: Hidden Dragon, Crouching Tiger and commented:
    Rule of Law over personal edicts start to hold sway. About time too.


    Posted by keeper @ chindia-alert | February 13, 2013, 10:13 pm
  2. No criminal defence lawyer should face detention for rightfully doing an exceptional job. And police officers or prosecutors who wrongfully exercise their duties for the sake of quota, and especially at the expense of five innocent lives, must face prosecution.


    Posted by Criminal Defence Lawyers - Melbourne | May 7, 2013, 4:15 pm


  1. Pingback: China says new military regulations on treason and deserting is “preparation for war” | China Daily Mail - March 29, 2013

  2. Pingback: China: Outrage among lawyers after official calls them ‘cowards’ | China Daily Mail - April 4, 2013

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

China News

China News is not affiliated in any way with any publication in China or anywhere else.

Enter your email address to receive an email each time an article is published, or join our RSS feed. 100% FREE.

Join 3,889 other followers

Want to write for China News?

Read “Contributor Guidelines” above to join our team of 84 contributors. Write news or opinion about issues in China, or post photos and video. Promote your own site.

Recent Posts

China News Articles Have Been Featured In:

%d bloggers like this: